Bill 1170 has crossed over from the Senate to the House. This means there are only two more steps to go. 1) The bill has to receive support (a yes vote) from the judiciary committee, and then 2) it goes to the floor of the House for a vote.
We need to help hurry the process along by contacting the Chair of the Judiciary Committee, Greg Delleney, and the members of the committee. This can be done in one email by clicking on the link below, filling in your information, and sending a short message.
http://www.scstatehouse.gov/email.php?T=C&C=H2000000200
I addressed my email "Dear Chairman Delleney and Members of the House Judiciary Committee:". Ask them to support the bill, explaining briefly that a second spouse should never have to pay or contribute to the alimony of the first, but that this happens in South Carolina, per court order. It happened to one of our members just a few months ago, even though the court ruled that her husband was not underemployed. In other words, the court did not think the husband was intentionally earning less money to reduce his alimony, but the judge ordered the second wife's income to be included anyway.
No one thinks this is right. This is an uncontroversial bill. Please send the judiciary committee an email asking for their support on Bill 1170. Let's get this passed this year!
Thank you for all of your support!
Our blog is a forum for second wives, partners, and anyone touched by the archaic alimony laws of the State of South Carolina to share their experiences, air grievances, and discuss goals to end permanent alimony in the state.
Friday, May 13, 2016
Monday, May 2, 2016
Support Bill 1170 as it moves to the House!
We are almost there! Take a few moments today to support Bill 1170 by letting your SC Representative know that you would appreciate his or her support on 1170. The vote in the House is the last step before 1170 becomes law. Your call and email can make all the difference! Tell your representative it is simply wrong for the income of a new spouse to be included when setting or modifying alimony for the ex-spouse. Bill 1170 fixes this.
To find your representative, go to http://www.scstatehouse.gov/legislatorssearch.php and enter your address and zip code. Click "Find legislators." Your legislators will pop up.
Call your Representative's Columbia business phone, and send an email by clicking "Send Message to Representative So-and-So."
Last week, 1170 made it through the Senate. Now it moves to the House. Your efforts can make all the difference. You can help 1170 become law!
As always, thank you so much for your support! Letting the legislators hear female voices is key to our success, because alimony reform is fighting for women, men, and families.
To find your representative, go to http://www.scstatehouse.gov/legislatorssearch.php and enter your address and zip code. Click "Find legislators." Your legislators will pop up.
Call your Representative's Columbia business phone, and send an email by clicking "Send Message to Representative So-and-So."
Last week, 1170 made it through the Senate. Now it moves to the House. Your efforts can make all the difference. You can help 1170 become law!
As always, thank you so much for your support! Letting the legislators hear female voices is key to our success, because alimony reform is fighting for women, men, and families.
Sunday, April 17, 2016
Bill S-1170: 2nd Wives Do Pay Their Husband's Alimony!!
If your income was included when the judge set or modified your husband's alimony payment, please call your state senator and state representative and tell them on Monday (4/18/16)! Bill S-1170 is up for a vote in the Senate on Tuesday of this week. Some don't believe this really happens--help change their minds. S-1170 bars the judge from considering the income of a subsequent spouse when setting alimony.
Despite all our efforts to educate the public and the legislators, people still have a hard time believing that second wives can end up paying the alimony of the first. You can understand why; the reaction is often one of disbelief. After all, it's a bit like cows eating cows. That's how we got mad cow disease. Second wives shouldn't pay alimony to someone they were never married to. It's obscene. But it happens.
Just a few months ago, in December of 2015, the husband of one of our members went to court, seeking a reduction in alimony, having found a new job that paid less than his previous employment. The court said he was not underemployed. In other words, he hadn't done anything wrong. In fact, he had worked hard to find employment after losing a job. He wasn't intentionally replacing an old job that paid more with one that paid less. And still, the judge ruled that “the court has discretion to consider a party’s new spouse’s income and contribution to expenses in determining the party’s alimony obligation.” That means that the second wife's income was taken into consideration when determining how much he could pay. Yes, second wives contribute to the alimony of the first in such cases! And no, the law does not protect them from this. In fact, case law shows that courts have refused to exclude the second spouse's income.
It is true that often times second wives end up paying alimony unofficially. Maybe your husband's business drops off, or his alimony is so high he can't make the payment on his own, even when he is receiving his normal income. With alimony payments that make up 1/3 to 1/2 of a payor's income, this is not surprising. You don't want him or her to go to jail (in some cases, the spouse paying alimony is female), so your income goes to the ex-spouse as well. This is bad enough. But it is really outrageous that a court would order a new spouse to contribute to the alimony of the ex-spouse. It is why some of our members will not marry their partners--they want to protect their hard-earned income.
It is outrageous that some legislators haven't take the testimony of citizens seriously! Thank you to the senators and representatives who do.
There is nothing controversial about this bill. It is pretty black and white. You shouldn't pay alimony to someone to whom you were never married. Call your senator and your representative and tell them so, especially if you are in that situation yourself!
Together, we can get this through.
Despite all our efforts to educate the public and the legislators, people still have a hard time believing that second wives can end up paying the alimony of the first. You can understand why; the reaction is often one of disbelief. After all, it's a bit like cows eating cows. That's how we got mad cow disease. Second wives shouldn't pay alimony to someone they were never married to. It's obscene. But it happens.
Just a few months ago, in December of 2015, the husband of one of our members went to court, seeking a reduction in alimony, having found a new job that paid less than his previous employment. The court said he was not underemployed. In other words, he hadn't done anything wrong. In fact, he had worked hard to find employment after losing a job. He wasn't intentionally replacing an old job that paid more with one that paid less. And still, the judge ruled that “the court has discretion to consider a party’s new spouse’s income and contribution to expenses in determining the party’s alimony obligation.” That means that the second wife's income was taken into consideration when determining how much he could pay. Yes, second wives contribute to the alimony of the first in such cases! And no, the law does not protect them from this. In fact, case law shows that courts have refused to exclude the second spouse's income.
It is true that often times second wives end up paying alimony unofficially. Maybe your husband's business drops off, or his alimony is so high he can't make the payment on his own, even when he is receiving his normal income. With alimony payments that make up 1/3 to 1/2 of a payor's income, this is not surprising. You don't want him or her to go to jail (in some cases, the spouse paying alimony is female), so your income goes to the ex-spouse as well. This is bad enough. But it is really outrageous that a court would order a new spouse to contribute to the alimony of the ex-spouse. It is why some of our members will not marry their partners--they want to protect their hard-earned income.
It is outrageous that some legislators haven't take the testimony of citizens seriously! Thank you to the senators and representatives who do.
There is nothing controversial about this bill. It is pretty black and white. You shouldn't pay alimony to someone to whom you were never married. Call your senator and your representative and tell them so, especially if you are in that situation yourself!
Together, we can get this through.
Friday, March 25, 2016
2016 2nd Wives and Partners Survey Results
As of the end of January 2016, we had 94 members in the 2nd Wives Club of South
Carolina. (We now have over 100!). 44% of our members answered
a recent survey. The statistics are telling:
- The length of the first marriage ranges from 7-30 years, yet all are paying permanent alimony.
- The professions of the husbands run the gamut. They are mechanics, physicians, salesmen, construction workers, attorneys, engineers, and business owners.
- While 88% of the second wives work, only 44% of the first wives do. The second wives who do not work are on disability. One is retired. The second wives work as administrators, ministers, teachers, professors, chefs, physicians, accountants, and in real estate and finance, to name but a few professions.
- Monthly alimony payments range from $300/month to $8000/month. The average alimony payment is $2,183.41.
- This amounts, on the average, to 33% of the husband’s income.
- Over half of the second wives have contributed to or paid the alimony of their husband’s ex-spouse, either short or long term (meaning more than a decade).
- While half of the first wives do have a college degree, the biggest complaint from the second wives survey participants is that the first wife is intentionally under-employed. Several participants wrote that their husband’s ex-spouse has declared her intent not to re-marry and to make her ex-husband pay until he dies. The survey participants comment that one should not be penalized for the rest of one’s life for a failed marriage, that this divorce without finality and separation is cruel, and that their husbands cannot retire.
- Some would-be second wives refuse to marry their partner, fearing they are putting their own finances in jeopardy, for example, if the first wife takes them back to court for more alimony based on their combined income. This happened--per a court order--to one of our members at the end of December 2015; her income was included to justify the alimony her husband had been ordered to pay, even though it was determined by the court that he was not underemployed!
The Second Wives and Partners Club of South Carolina inherited its name from similar organizations in other states. The purpose of the Second Wives is to emphasize that permanent periodic alimony negatively impacts the lives of women, children, and men.
Please support Alimony Reform in South Carolina. We believe alimony has its place, to provide equity for both parties at the end of the marriage. But in this day and age, permanent alimony should no longer be the most common form of alimony awarded in South Carolina.
Monday, May 11, 2015
Who Are the Second Wives and Partners? What Can You Do?
We are women (and their partners) who believe that the alimony laws in the state of South Carolina are outdated, specifically the awarding of permanent alimony as the most common form of alimony awarded. Many of us have been directly harmed by these laws. We may actually be the ones paying our spouse's alimony, because he has suffered a financial downturn. We may not be able to retire, along with our spouse, because our husbands owe their ex-wives so much in alimony each month that retirement is impossible. We may be struggling to put children through college, perhaps step-children whose mother is receiving the money in alimony that should be going toward the childrens' college education. The ways in which the old laws are one-sided are endless. Even short marriages can result in permanent alimony.
Our goal is to educate the public and our legislators concerning the inequities the old laws have created. We no longer live in a society where the majority of women stay home with their children while their husbands work. What the old laws have created is a system wherein there is no incentive for women receiving permanent alimony, many of whom are college-educated and have had good paying jobs in the past, to work or to look for new, long-term relationships. They often remain mired in the past, financially and emotionally, which also damages their children. Many of these men have become walking annuities; the pressure is tremendous. We believe that temporary alimony has its place, but permanent alimony in this day and age is inequitable.
Over the last few months, just about every day, one or several new members have joined the 2nd Wives Club. SC Alimony Reform (which has hundreds of members!) has been very busy this winter and into the spring--meeting with Senators and Representatives; putting up billboards; recording radio and television ads; writing hardship stories of members who have suffered terribly under South Carolina's archaic alimony laws and getting these stories to the media; working with a lobbyist; writing letters to editors; doing television, newspaper, and radio interviews; and donating to fund the advertising when we can. SC Alimony Reform bumper stickers have become more and more visible. Perhaps you, too, have been involved in these efforts!
Help us bring South Carolina's alimony laws up-to-date. We have introduced bill H-3215, which calls for a task force to create new and equitable laws. Call and write your legislators (specifically the senators below), and ask them to support bill H-3215. Good law should be able to protect the interests of all sides within reason. Help us make South Carolina a state where people don't think twice about getting married.
Bill H-3215 has already passed in the House. Please use the link below to contact senators on the Senate Judiciary Committee, asking them to support the bill, so that it will move to a vote in the Senate next. The link allows you to send an email to all members of the Senate Judiciary Committee at once.
http://www.scstatehouse.gov/committee.php?chamber=S#jud
Thank you for your time and continued efforts!
Our goal is to educate the public and our legislators concerning the inequities the old laws have created. We no longer live in a society where the majority of women stay home with their children while their husbands work. What the old laws have created is a system wherein there is no incentive for women receiving permanent alimony, many of whom are college-educated and have had good paying jobs in the past, to work or to look for new, long-term relationships. They often remain mired in the past, financially and emotionally, which also damages their children. Many of these men have become walking annuities; the pressure is tremendous. We believe that temporary alimony has its place, but permanent alimony in this day and age is inequitable.
Over the last few months, just about every day, one or several new members have joined the 2nd Wives Club. SC Alimony Reform (which has hundreds of members!) has been very busy this winter and into the spring--meeting with Senators and Representatives; putting up billboards; recording radio and television ads; writing hardship stories of members who have suffered terribly under South Carolina's archaic alimony laws and getting these stories to the media; working with a lobbyist; writing letters to editors; doing television, newspaper, and radio interviews; and donating to fund the advertising when we can. SC Alimony Reform bumper stickers have become more and more visible. Perhaps you, too, have been involved in these efforts!
Help us bring South Carolina's alimony laws up-to-date. We have introduced bill H-3215, which calls for a task force to create new and equitable laws. Call and write your legislators (specifically the senators below), and ask them to support bill H-3215. Good law should be able to protect the interests of all sides within reason. Help us make South Carolina a state where people don't think twice about getting married.
Bill H-3215 has already passed in the House. Please use the link below to contact senators on the Senate Judiciary Committee, asking them to support the bill, so that it will move to a vote in the Senate next. The link allows you to send an email to all members of the Senate Judiciary Committee at once.
http://www.scstatehouse.gov/committee.php?chamber=S#jud
Thank you for your time and continued efforts!
Sunday, February 15, 2015
We Are Growing Like Crazy!
It is so exciting to be in contact with so many new members of the 2nd Wives and Partners Club! Since South Carolina Alimony Reform has become more visible to the public through billboards, articles in The State Newspaper, radio ads, and interviews by Fox News in Greenville and WISTV in Columbia, the word is getting out. You and your partner do not have to suffer under the burden of permanent alimony alone. And, the laws can be changed!
We have had several fruitful meetings with senators and representatives in the last few weeks, explaining the impact of the antiquated alimony laws on South Carolina families today. Very few people are aware that permanent alimony is the most common form of alimony awarded in this state, often even when the marriage lasted less than ten years and the individuals have a lifetime ahead of them. The lawmakers we approached agree that it is time to take a look at the old laws on the books in the context of the modern economy.
So many have asked me--what can I do? There are several things:
1) Write your the legislators (senator and representative) from your district a letter or email, explaining how the laws are hurting you and your family and how you would like to see the law changed. Ask them for their help and support on this matter. Specifically, South Carolina Alimony Reform has proposed a bill, filed by Jerry Govan, calling for the formation of a task force to revise the old laws. Ask your legislators to support this bill.
2) Write your local paper. An editorial or opinion piece lets the public know what the current law is (most people don't believe you when you say permanent means forever) and how you would like to see it changed. This will let others in the same boat know they are not alone.
3) Comment on this blog--let your story speak for itself. Let your voice be heard.
We can get the laws changed in this state. The 2nd Wives have been instrumental in other states, helping the public to see that both women and men are negatively impacted by old laws that no longer reflect the economic reality of modern families.
Welcome new members! We know the laws can be changed, because it has been done in other states, and Florida and New Jersey are in the midst of reform initiatives as well. There is a real sense of momentum. Thank you for your support!
We have had several fruitful meetings with senators and representatives in the last few weeks, explaining the impact of the antiquated alimony laws on South Carolina families today. Very few people are aware that permanent alimony is the most common form of alimony awarded in this state, often even when the marriage lasted less than ten years and the individuals have a lifetime ahead of them. The lawmakers we approached agree that it is time to take a look at the old laws on the books in the context of the modern economy.
So many have asked me--what can I do? There are several things:
1) Write your the legislators (senator and representative) from your district a letter or email, explaining how the laws are hurting you and your family and how you would like to see the law changed. Ask them for their help and support on this matter. Specifically, South Carolina Alimony Reform has proposed a bill, filed by Jerry Govan, calling for the formation of a task force to revise the old laws. Ask your legislators to support this bill.
2) Write your local paper. An editorial or opinion piece lets the public know what the current law is (most people don't believe you when you say permanent means forever) and how you would like to see it changed. This will let others in the same boat know they are not alone.
3) Comment on this blog--let your story speak for itself. Let your voice be heard.
We can get the laws changed in this state. The 2nd Wives have been instrumental in other states, helping the public to see that both women and men are negatively impacted by old laws that no longer reflect the economic reality of modern families.
Welcome new members! We know the laws can be changed, because it has been done in other states, and Florida and New Jersey are in the midst of reform initiatives as well. There is a real sense of momentum. Thank you for your support!
Thursday, December 18, 2014
Second Wives of South Carolina Meet
Friday, December 12th, The Second Wives Club met to discuss the coming legislative session. We came to a consensus on the following:
- End permanent alimony. We share the common goal of ending permanent alimony in the state in favor of rehabilitative (temporary) alimony to be paid to the lesser earning spouse over a period of time appropriate to the length of the marriage, if indeed there is a large income disparity between the divorcing parties. This will allow both parties to plan for their financial well-being accordingly. This will make it possible for parents to pay for college tuition for their children, rather than support a fully-grown ex-spouse, since paying for both is impossible. This will allow everyone to retire upon reaching retirement age. And it encourages the individuals to get on with their lives in a healthy way.
- Guidelines. Alimony should be determined according to a clear set of guidelines, rather than the cumbersome and lengthy list of factors currently left up to the discretion of the judge, which has led to inconsistent rulings.
- Purpose of alimony. It is a well-known myth that both parties can maintain the same standard of living upon divorce, since two households have been established. Why then is this language still used to describe the purpose of alimony and how much the lesser earning spouse should receive? Instead, we would like to see language that reflects the desire of the divorcing parties to be treated fairly, which might include rehabilitative alimony for the lesser earning spouse. The purpose of alimony should be to enable the lesser earning spouse to move towards financial independence through rehabilitative alimony for a length of time appropriate for the length of the marriage. This also means that alimony can never be raised above its original amount, as this would make the payor more responsible for the payee than at the time of divorce, which is not the purpose of alimony.
- Ability to pay. This is an unfair standard sometimes used to justify making the payor tap into retirement funds or take out costly loans to pay alimony he or she cannot afford, even after losing a job or experiencing a decline in income. Often, payors must go to these extremes or face going to jail. In this economy, imputing income (a judge saying how much an individual should be able to generate) is an unfair practice.
- Seeking adjustments/reductions in alimony. It must be possible to seek adjustments in alimony when circumstances change. This means that the income and assets of the payee (the ex-spouse receiving alimony) should also be taken into consideration.
- Co-habitation. Current rulings on co-habitation are unsatisfactory. For example, if a boyfriend or girlfriend leaves the home for a weekend, the 90 day co-habitation period may begin again. This clearly is not the intent of the law, which seeks to ensure that an individual paying alimony is not supporting an ex-spouse and his or her new partner.
- Earnings and Assets of the Second Wife. The second wife's income and assets should never be taken into consideration when determining alimony. Making a couple financially responsible for a first wife in no way speaks to the purpose of alimony, nor does it reflect the reality of most women who work outside the home and perhaps also raise children. Good law encourages the independence of divorcing parties in an economy where both men and women work. Second wives have worked to achieve their own financial independence and should never have to contribute to the alimony of the first wife.
~The Second Wives Club of South Carolina
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)